A Journey to East Timor
by Peter Williamson
Arriving
in Dili on a domestic flight from Bali, an "immigration"
officer calls me aside to fill in forms. This does little to enhance
the argument that East Timor is fully integrated into the country
as the 27th province of Indonesia. So begins a few weeks of continual
questioning by the authorities - often I was not sure which authority
- on my reasons for being in East Timor.
Within hours
of arriving I am hit with a sense of the oppression, of the quiet
desperation of the people. As I walk down a street, a voice calls
out the freedom slogan "Viva Timor L'este!" just loud
enough for me to hear. People insist that I photograph them, even
demand it. Before the moment of exposure they flash two fingers
in the victory sign, small acts of defiance to ensure that I take
home some evidence, however intangible, of ongoing resistance to
Indonesian authority.
I am frequently
questioned about my background. My questioners seem determined to
find out whether or not I am a journalist - even to trick me into
saying that I am - and what exactly my profession is.
One man
present is later introduced as a "captain in the intelligence".
On learning I am from Sydney, he asks me if I know José Ramos Horta:
"No."
"Do
you know who he is?"
"Yes."
"How
do you know?"
"Well,
he has just won the Nobel Peace Prize; he's in the news a fair bit."
"Oh.
Do you know..." and so on.
Knowledge
arouses suspicion for such people. So does any interest in local
economic or social conditions. Implicit in the rules, and the general
attitude of the Indonesian authorities, is an idea that tourists
are not interested in politics or human rights. Anyone with
such interests cannot be a genuine tourist.
I meet some
people said to be from the resistance. I am shown photographs of
young Timorese who have been tortured and murdered by the military.
Their bodies are beaten and bloody, and the Timorese flag has been
draped over them for some pictures. I ask in amazement how they
were able to get such pictures, and I am told that the torturers,
who made the photos and also appear in the pictures, sold the pictures
to them. As I leave, I am urged to take photos of military cemeteries:
"Why?"
I ask.
"Because
we want the world to see that the fight is still going on, and that
Indonesian soldiers are still being killed."
Each grave
of an Indonesian soldier is a symbol of the success of the resistance
- like a trophy staking a claim to the vigour of their struggle.
I am amazed
that the students will risk so much for the sake of seeing a few
photographs reach the outside world. Again and again, I have similar
experiences. People beg me, implore me, even demand that I make
defiant photographs of them to show the world that the resistance
is still alive and strong in East Timor.
On the streets
I hear rumours of demonstrations that may or may not happen. I am
approached a number of times by young men: "Do you want to
see a demo. Tomorrow at ten o'clock. Just follow the people and
you will find it."
On Palm
Sunday I am the only foreigner amongst hundreds gathered in the
church grounds, for the church cannot contain such a crowd. After
it is over, some young men urge me to follow them. I sense that
something has happened. I am hurried behind an outbuilding where
a makeshift clinic has been established and some nuns are tending
to four injured men. They have been beaten by the military in an
early morning demonstration to mark the arrival of Jamsheed Marker,
UN Special Envoy to East Timor. One man has been shot, but it seems
he will survive. They do not seek treatment at a hospital as they
say they would be arrested there and face possible detention and
torture. I am told to take photographs, and then a four-page manifesto
is thrust into my hands as I leave.
A rumour
says that forty people have been arrested; another says that four
people have died. Later I hear six. I want to leave the church,
but police or troops in riot gear have blocked off the roads. I
find a Timorese taxi driver and ask him to get me out of there.
This he does via back streets and I return to my guest house rather
shaken. It is time to leave Dili.
Some Timorese
say that this demonstration, and many others, has been arranged
by the Indonesian Intelligence. Others say that the demo was to
have taken place at 10am, but the Indonesians spread false rumours
that it had been changed to 6am. It is a strategy designed to confuse
the people and undermine the protest, so that the visiting media
would miss the show.
The use
of informers and stooges causes great resentment, splitting the
Timorese people and placing them in awful dilemmas. People who have
or want government jobs are under particular pressure. The cost
of a job can be betrayal of your people.
On minibuses
known as microlets, I travel to regional towns - Ermera, Venilale,
Viqueque, Maubisse, Los Palos, Suai. The names are exotic, so un-Asian
with their Portuguese spelling. Not much of the Portuguese architecture
remains - a few churches, houses and schools with graceful arches
and terracotta tiles. The language is still widely spoken by people
of about 40 and older. My rusty Portuguese is called into urgent
service and I manage, at least, to forge some kind of communication
with the Timorese. They love to talk, but any mention of politics
provokes a barrier which may terminate the encounter.
Microlets
are brightly coloured, with names such as Phoebe, Adelaide, Travolta,
Traque de Victoria, Quo Vadis, Shirley and Amanda. Along winding
roads, overworked tape players pump out Timorese pop. We stop every
few minutes to pick up or drop off passengers. An oversized westerner
with an oversized backpack, I am crushed into the back with the
friendly Timorese. Mostly we manage to exchange words and gestures;
occasionally someone speaks some English or we battle on in Portuguese.
My dictionary is always close at hand.
I am high
in the hills and mist is wafting through the town. It is late afternoon,
and getting cold. As I amble past a market with women selling their
meagre produce - a neat pile of chillis, lemons stacked like marbles
on a ragged mat - a policeman calls me to the station. My arrival
and lack of Indonesian language causes concern. Soldiers radio to
headquarters awaiting instructions for dealing with the tourist.
An hour later I am free to go, but I must also report to the military
police.
They ask
me trivial questions. I feel they want to delay me, to waste my
time. I try to be friendly; a soldier talks of East Timor as a hardship
posting. A policeman from Kalimantan says he wants to go home, but
transfers are not easily arranged. He could resign from the force,
but he fears he could not support his wife and children.
There is
no accommodation in the town. I am offered the concrete floor of
the station, but this option does not appeal and I decide to try
the church. I go looking for the priest and find myself at the nuns
house:
"Good
afternoon, Madré..."
"I
can't speak to you about the situation. If you are looking for the
women, they are not here."
"Which
women?"
"They
are not here."
"I'm
actually looking for the priest."
"Oh,
you'll find him in that house over there."
The priest
puts me up in a room kept for seminarians; we eat the best meal
I've had in East Timor. I ask about "the women" and what
is going on. In a hushed voice he tells me that there has been an
incident in which two young women were arrested by soldiers who
claimed that the women were trying to make contact with guerillas.
They were repeatedly raped and beaten. A church delegation from
Dili has just secured their release and they are now being cared
for by the nuns. No charges have been laid against the soldiers.
Next day
I travel on. Whole hillsides are eroding, denuded of trees. Large
rivers have silted up, their beds littered with trunks of washed
away trees. The once plentiful sandalwood is gone - exploited by
the Portuguese and finished off by the new colonists in Jakarta.
It is the poorest province of Indonesia by any measure, and one
of the poorest places I have seen. There is little evidence of industry.
There are few private cars. Almost all shops appear to be owned
and run by Indonesian immigrants, gradually moving in from the islands
to the west - Java, Bali, Flores or Sumatra. The Timorese are mainly
subsistence farmers, increasingly marginalised in their own land.
Many of
the educated elite fled to Portugal and Australia in the years following
the invasion. A nun tells me how at the age of one she fled to the
mountains with her family to escape the war in the towns. At the
age of two she learned how to keep quiet and still, already understanding
that her life depended on it. She endured bombing raids and once
was separated from her parents for three weeks, surviving with other
children on roots and berries. Incredibly, all her immediate family
survived the three years in the mountains, but she saw her pregnant
aunt die when her child was cut from her belly by an Indonesian
soldier.
Such stories
are common in East Timor. Well over a hundred thousand Timorese
died in the war, many of starvation. No one knows how many, but
it may have been a quarter of the entire population. I ask another
nun about the psychological trauma accompanying such a legacy. "No-one
ever asks about that," she says, and goes on to tell me about
cases in the village where she works.
She is a
foreigner and thought nothing of playing a prank with the children
she was minding in an orphanage. Another nun was returning from
town and as she heard the car pull up outside, she said "Quick,
let's hide so Sister will think we're not here!" A girl broke
into hysterical sobbing and shaking and could not be consoled. The
childs terror of hiding from the soldiers has been reawakened.
Others she spoke of wandered aimlessly round the village, lost in
their tortuous worlds. One woman regularly wakes her in the night,
hysterically screaming that the soldiers have killed her family;
this is true but the killings occurred years before.
In Maubisse
I get stuck, having missed the day's last bus to Ainaro. A man approaches
me in the market and says "come with me". He is not in
uniform, but claims to be a policeman. At the police station we
go through the usual questions and filling in of forms. Some police
are playing soccer on a lawn and I ask if I can take a photograph.
They are happy, but the commander shouts "No, no!" Across
the road is a cemetery, and I am not to photograph that. In fact,
he indicates that I am not even to visit the cemetery. Later, I
discover that the cemetery contains mass graves - entire families
who all died on the same day. It is telling evidence of the atrocities
against civilians, including women and children.
The restriction
annoys me and I walk back along the road to the guest house which
sits atop a small hill. I watch rain clouds receding across the
valley and the mountains; the sun breaks through and a soft light
falls onto the cemetery, little crosses on a green rise on the edge
of town. I feel a strange and unspecific anger rise up inside me.
I think of the waste of life, the suffering, and the injustice of
twenty-two years of occupation. I think of the faces I have seen,
worn down by years of hardship, the desperation in the eyes of the
many people I have met. I think of Linda, a student I met in another
town. We talked and joked in her house - her mother correcting my
rudimentary Portuguese, feeding me biscuits and coffee, asking me
about Australia. She avoids my attempts to turn the talk to the
"situation" in East Timor, then through her silence I
detect an awful fear that my visit will bring trouble to her family.
I think
of her and how I did not visit again for fear of bringing trouble
to her family; I was being watched and questioned by intelligence
officers. In an idle aside I said that I did not trust politicians
- they were all crooks - Suharto included. The room fell silent
and I thought "This is it - I'm going to be charged with something.
Insulting the president. Maybe I'll just be deported". Nothing
happened, but I was too concerned to drop in again. I wish I had
her address, or her surname, but what could I write anyway?
In my room
the lights do not work, so I lie in my sleeping bag, thinking that
travels in East Timor cannot leave a thinking person unchanged.
There are so few tourists (I have seen only two in as many weeks);
every tourist must get some sense of the Timorese people's reaching
out to them, at the same time as noticing their deep fear of saying
the wrong thing to the wrong person. There is an atmosphere of paranoia
and suspicion. Anyone could be an informer, a spy.
My last
stop is Ocussi where I watch from the bus as we pass a dozen or
more burnt out buildings, the only remaining indication of Timorese
anger and resentment of Indonesian traders in a riot a few months
earlier. I climb a hill to see some statues of Christ with animals
at his feet. The sun glints sharply off the Sawu Sea. It is hot
and quiet. I try to reconcile what I have seen in the weeks gone
by, but I cannot digest it yet. Perhaps later it will fall into
place. Leaving feels like walking out on a people in need of friends.
Perhaps I should not have gone to look, but I think of what one
Timorese said to me:
"People
must come. We want tourists. We want them to see what is going on,
how we must live."
The presence
of tourists offers the Timorese a small degree of protection. If
something terrible happens, then someone may find out. It is not
a fun place to travel; the accommodation and the food are poor.
In many towns you cannot find a cold drink. But East Timor will
stay on my mind for years to come. It pricks your conscience. They
are probably right in saying that the more people who go, the sooner
the world will stand up to Indonesia and say "Enough is enough".
Peter Williamson
is a freelance journalist and photographer. He traveled to East
Timor in 1997
|